Laptops

Dell XPS Googlebook vs MacBook Neo: $1,800 Is Not $699

Dell XPS Googlebook VS Apple MacBook Neo
🏆 Winner: Apple MacBook Neo
Dell XPS Googlebook vs Apple MacBook Neo - Laptops comparison

PCMag on October 24 sat Google’s first Googlebook wave against MacBooks and still handed price, and the overall line, to Apple. The Dell XPS Googlebook is the thin one in that roundup: 13.4 inches, 2.2 pounds, two USB-C 3.2 ports, $1,799.99 at the top configuration. CNET still has the MacBook Neo at $699 as reviewed, 2.7 pounds, A18 Pro, 8GB, 256GB, a 36.5Wh battery, and nearly 13.5 hours on a YouTube drain test. That is $1,100 of sticker. It is not two extra ports.

We already ran Neo against a Windows XPS 13 and Neo against Air M5. This week the named Dell is a Googlebook. Do not paste the Wildcat Lake XPS 13 review onto it. Different OS. Different ports. Different $1,800.

$1,799.99 is a top XPS. $699 is a Neo that already got hiked.

PCMag’s price table is ugly for Google. Googlebooks start at $899.99 for the Acer and cap at $1,799.99 for the top-configured Dell XPS Googlebook. The line, in that piece, is “essentially a powerful Android tablet with a keyboard permanently attached.” That sentence is the tax. You are paying XPS money for Android-in-clamshell.

The 13-inch MacBook Air starts at $1,299 in the same comparison, matching HP’s Googlebook. Configure an Air to $1,799 and PCMag says you have a more capable laptop than Dell’s similarly priced XPS Googlebook. Then the Neo undercuts the cheapest Googlebook. PCMag: the Neo is a more potent laptop in some ways for even less than the cheapest Googlebook, and it has Siri AI and Apple Intelligence at $699.

CNET’s Neo review is the receipt for that $699. It debuted at $599. RAM shortage and component costs forced a June hike. As reviewed now: $699, £699, AU$1,049. Do not quote $599 as if the shelf still says it. The hike is the story. It is still $200 under Acer’s Googlebook floor and $1,100 under Dell’s ceiling.

If your budget is $700, there is no XPS Googlebook in the conversation. If your budget is $1,800, PCMag is telling you to look at a loaded Air before you look at a loaded Dell Googlebook. This page is the $1,800-versus-$699 fight because that is the named pair. Winner at the sticker: Neo. Winner if you insist on the 2.2-pound XPS shell: you still bought Android.

2.2 pounds is the XPS shell. 2.7 is still a bag laptop.

PCMag: Googlebooks run 13 to 15 inches, 0.5 to 0.63 inch thick, all metal. The 13.4-inch Dell XPS Googlebook is 2.2 pounds. The 15.3-inch Lenovo Googlebook is 2.84 pounds. Fingerprint reader in the power-button key on every Googlebook. Backlit lattice or chiclet on every Googlebook except HP. Most trackpads are hinge mechanisms; Lenovo uses haptics.

CNET’s Neo: 2.7 pounds (1.2 kg), 13-inch panel. You give up 0.5 pounds to Dell and you keep macOS. If weight is the only column, Dell wins. If weight is the column you use to justify $1,100, weigh the charger too. CNET: Neo ships a 20W USB-C adapter, no MagSafe, slower charge than the Air’s 40- to 60-watt brick. PCMag: Air has MagSafe plus two Thunderbolt 4. Neo bucks that with slower USB-C and no MagSafe. XPS Googlebook, in PCMag’s port section, is the unfortunate exception in the Googlebook line: just two USB-C 3.2. Several other first Googlebooks mix Thunderbolt 4 with USB-A and HDMI. Dell did the thin trick and deleted the ports.

Two USB-C 3.2 on a $1,800 clamshell is how you buy a dongle and then defend Android. Neo at least is honest about being a cheap Mac. It has USB 3 USB-C, USB 2 USB-C, and a headphone jack, per CNET. Slow. Named. $699.

PCMag hands ports to Googlebooks as a line. Dell is the one that does not deserve that win. If you wanted HDMI and USB-A, buy the Googlebook that actually has them, not the XPS badge.

120Hz touch is the Googlebook mandate. 60Hz is the Mac.

PCMag says Google likely mandates a floor: at least 1600p, max 1800p, touch, 120Hz max refresh, up to 500 nits. MacBook Air and Neo: 500 nits, 60Hz. Neo 219 ppi, Air 224 ppi. Mac panels meet P3 on IPS, some with True Tone. PCMag still gives displays to Googlebooks because Macs are behind on refresh, overall color, and touch.

CNET’s Neo lab: 13-inch, 2,480×1,506, rated 500 nits, measured 518 nits on a Spyder X Elite. M5 Air hit 500 on the nose. Neo was a bit brighter than the M5 Air in that test. 60Hz is still 60Hz. If you want 120Hz touch, Dell’s Googlebook is in the mandated club. PCMag did not print the XPS Googlebook’s exact resolution in the chunks we have. Do not invent 1800p on the Dell. Print the mandate, then go look at the spec sheet on the cart.

Touch on a laptop is a finger on a glossy panel. If you do not poke the screen, you paid for a digitizer and a 120Hz scaler you will run at 60 in a bag. Neo does not pretend. It is an IPS you look at.

36.5Wh is the Neo battery. Android is not a 13.5-hour alibi.

CNET: Neo 36.5Wh versus Air 53.8Wh. YouTube drain: nearly 13.5 hours on the Neo, about 3.5 hours shorter than the M5 Air, more than 2 hours shorter than the M1 Air (58.2Wh). CNET also saw longer runtimes on Snapdragon X and Intel Lunar Lake / Panther Lake Windows machines. 13.5 hours is still a workday. It is not Air.

PCMag did not give us a YouTube number for the XPS Googlebook in the extract. Do not invent one. What PCMag did say: Continue On, Google’s handoff story, worked after much cajoling and is inconsistent, tied to Wi-Fi and Bluetooth, and suffers with distance or walls. That is not battery life. That is a feature that needs two radios and a calm room.

If you buy the Dell for “all-day Android,” demand the hour count on the product page. A 2.2-pound shell does not imply a 53Wh brick. Neo publishes 36.5Wh. Believe the watt-hours.

A18 Pro 8GB is a constraint. Android-with-a-keyboard is another.

CNET as reviewed: A18 Pro 6-core CPU (2P, 4E), 5-core GPU, 8GB unified memory, 256GB SSD, Wi-Fi 6E, Bluetooth 6, macOS Tahoe 26.3.1. Multicore Geekbench 6 and Cinebench 2024 put it near or at the back of CNET’s Mac pack. It edged the M1 Air on Geekbench 6 multicore. It finished ahead of Dell’s Neo competitor, the XPS 13, in that chart. That XPS 13 is the Windows one. It is not the Googlebook. Do not steal the chart.

PCMag’s insult is the useful one for the Googlebook: a powerful Android tablet with a keyboard glued on. If your apps are Android-first and you live in Gemini, the Dell shell is a better phone dock than a Neo. If your apps are browser, IDE, and a VM, $1,800 of Android is a dare. PCMag’s overall line winner is MacBooks. The Neo is the machine they hold up at the end of the price section.

8GB on the Neo is the asterisk we already know. CNET’s table is 8GB. Do not sell it as a 16GB Air. $699 is the compensation. $1,800 on Dell does not automatically mean 16GB either unless the cart says so. PCMag did not print the XPS Googlebook RAM in the extract. Open the configure page.

Siri AI and Apple Intelligence at $699 is PCMag’s software jab. Google will talk Gemini. Continue On is the Gemini-adjacent feature PCMag already found fussy. Pick the assistant you will actually leave on. Then pick the laptop that is not $1,100 more for two slow USB-C ports.

CNET also ran Chromebook benchmarks on the Neo because $699 sits in that aisle. Spoiler, in their words: the Neo dusted the Chromebooks. That is useful only as a floor. A Googlebook is not the Chromebooks CNET used as cannon fodder. It is a new Google OS family with 120Hz touch and XPS prices. Do not take “dusted Chromebooks” as “dusted Dell Googlebook.” Different machines. Different year. The $1,800 still needs an app list.

Charging is the daily tax. CNET: USB-C on the Neo does not snap in like MagSafe, and the 20W brick does not charge like the Air’s 40- to 60-watt pack. PCMag already noted MagSafe on Air and its absence on Neo. The XPS Googlebook extract did not print adapter wattage. If Dell shipped a 60W GaN in the box, that is a point. If they shipped a phone brick, you paid XPS money for phone charging. Check the box weight, not the press photo.

CNET’s comparison table still lists a Windows Dell XPS 13 at 8GB and 16GB, Core 5 320, 512GB. That is the other Dell. It is the one we already compared to the Neo. Mixing that table into a Googlebook cart is how you buy the wrong SKU at Best Buy. Match “Googlebook” on the hinge sticker.

Winner: Neo, unless the 2.2-pound Android is the job.

PCMag gave Googlebooks displays and, as a line, ports. It gave MacBooks price. Dell’s XPS Googlebook is the Googlebook that fails the ports win and owns the price loss. CNET’s Neo is still the $699 Mac with a measured 518 nits and a 36.5Wh pack.

Acer’s Googlebook 14, in PCMag’s own card, starts at $899 and scored 4.0 Excellent. If Android-in-clamshell is the experiment, start there. The XPS badge is how the experiment becomes $1,800. Lenovo’s 15.3-inch Googlebook at 2.84 pounds is the other size class. PCMag credited several first Googlebooks with Thunderbolt 4 plus USB-A and HDMI. Dell was the exception. Pay for the exception only if 2.2 pounds is non-negotiable.

CNET says seven months in, the Neo helped a Mac sales surge and showed up in Tim Cook’s last earnings call. That is Apple’s problem. Your problem is whether $699 of 8GB macOS beats $1,800 of XPS Android. This week the reviews say yes, unless your apps never left the Play Store.

Buy the Neo if you want macOS, a named battery test, and a number that is not $1,800. Buy the XPS Googlebook if 2.2 pounds, 120Hz touch, and Android apps are the job and you already know the two USB-C 3.2 ports are a dongle. Do not buy the XPS badge because the Windows XPS 13 was thin last year. This one is a Googlebook. The OS is the product. The $1,100 is the argument.